TBIModerate evidence evidenceNarrative Review and Clinical Commentary
Cervicogenic Contributions to Persistent Post-Concussion Symptoms
This brief explores the significant role of the cervical spine in persistent post-concussion symptoms like headaches, dizziness, and neck pain. We will delve into the latest evidence on manual therapy, cervical proprioception training, and multimodal approaches to help you effectively manage these complex patients.
Research: November 2024
Related Videos
Cervicogenic Headache: Concussion Questions
Treatment for Cervicogenic Headaches
Key Findings
1Cervical spine dysfunction is a common and significant contributor to persistent post-concussion symptoms.
2Sensorimotor deficits, particularly impaired joint position error (JPE), can persist even after other concussion symptoms have resolved.
3A multimodal approach combining manual therapy and cervical proprioception training is effective in treating cervicogenic dysfunction post-concussion.
4Early assessment and treatment of the cervical spine may prevent prolonged recovery from concussion.
5Pain on manual segmental testing of the upper cervical spine is a key feature of a cervicogenic component in post-concussion patients.
As clinicians, we're seeing more patients with persistent symptoms after a concussion, and it's clear that a one-size-fits-all approach doesn't work. The evidence strongly suggests that for many of these patients, the neck is a major, often overlooked, contributor to their ongoing symptoms. A 2024 study in the *Annals of Medicine* highlights that the mechanisms of a concussion often involve a whiplash-like trauma to the cervical spine, leading to dysfunction that can mimic or exacerbate concussion symptoms. This is a crucial paradigm shift for our practice – we need to be looking at the neck in every concussion patient.
The research shows that up to 85% of patients with persistent post-concussion symptoms have moderate to severe pain with manual mobility testing of the upper cervical spine. This isn't just a simple neck strain; we're talking about underlying sensorimotor deficits. The 2024 Kinney et al. study found significant impairments in joint position error (JPE) in post-concussion patients, even when their primary concussion symptoms had nearly resolved. This tells us that even when patients feel better, their cervical spine might still be dysfunctional, setting them up for chronic problems down the road.
So, what does this mean for our clinical practice? It means we need to be assessing the cervical spine in every concussion patient, not just those with obvious neck pain. A thorough assessment should include manual segmental mobility testing of the upper and lower cervical spine, as well as an evaluation of cervical proprioception using JPE testing. For JPE testing, you can use a head-mounted laser and a target to measure the patient's ability to return to a neutral head position with their eyes closed. An error of greater than 7cm is considered abnormal and indicates a proprioceptive deficit.
Once we've identified these cervical impairments, we can target them with specific interventions. The evidence supports a multimodal approach that combines manual therapy, cervical proprioception training, and other modalities. Manual therapy techniques like mobilizations and manipulations of the upper cervical spine (C0-C3) have been shown to reduce pain and improve mobility. For proprioception, exercises that challenge the patient's head and neck awareness are key. This can include things like laser-guided head movements to trace patterns on a wall, or gaze stability exercises while moving the head.
When it comes to dosing, the research provides some guidance. For manual therapy, we're looking at 1-2 sessions per week for 4-6 weeks. For proprioceptive training, daily exercises are often recommended, with a focus on quality of movement over quantity. A typical program might involve 3-5 exercises, with 10-15 repetitions each. It's important to start with a low level of challenge and gradually progress as the patient's symptoms allow. We also need to be mindful of contraindications and precautions. Red flags for manual therapy include signs of vertebral artery insufficiency, spinal cord compression, or fracture. For patients with severe irritability, it's best to start with gentle, pain-free techniques.
Patient selection is also critical. Patients with a history of whiplash-like injury, neck pain, dizziness, or cervicogenic headaches are prime candidates for this approach. However, given the high prevalence of cervical dysfunction in this population, it's worth screening all concussion patients for these impairments. By addressing the cervical spine, we can help our patients break the cycle of persistent symptoms and get back to their lives. The integration of these principles into our practice is not just an option, but a necessity for providing the best possible care to our patients. The evidence is clear: a happy neck means a happy head.
Clinician's Note
I've found that addressing the cervical spine is a game-changer for many of my post-concussion patients. It's often the missing piece of the puzzle that helps them finally break free from the cycle of persistent symptoms. Don't be afraid to get your hands on these patients and really assess their cervical mobility and proprioception. You'll be surprised at what you find, and your patients will thank you for it.
Clinic Action Plan
[
"1. Screen all concussion patients for cervical spine dysfunction, regardless of whether they report neck pain.",
"2. Perform a thorough cervical spine assessment, including manual segmental mobility testing and joint position error (JPE) testing.",
"3. Develop a multimodal treatment plan that includes manual therapy to address joint restrictions and proprioceptive exercises to improve sensorimotor control.",
"4. Educate patients on the role of the cervical spine in their symptoms and the importance of adherence to their home exercise program.",
"5. Monitor patient progress closely and adjust the treatment plan as needed, progressing exercises and techniques as tolerated.",
"6. Collaborate with other healthcare professionals to ensure comprehensive and coordinated care for your patients."
]
Common Mistakes to Avoid
•1. Focusing solely on the brain and ignoring the cervical spine.
•2. Only treating patients who report neck pain, and not screening all concussion patients for cervical dysfunction.
•3. Using a generic, one-size-fits-all approach to treatment, rather than a targeted, multimodal approach.
•4. Not progressing exercises and techniques as the patient's symptoms improve.
•5. Failing to educate patients on the role of the cervical spine in their symptoms and the importance of their home exercise program.
Frequently Asked Questions
Premium Deep Dive
This brief includes an extended deep-dive section with clinical nuance, dosing details, edge cases, and special population considerations.